Let me just preface this right now. I am not advocating that we shouldn’t cast anySurvivorplayers on shows likeThe TraitorsandDeal or No Deal Island. In fact, let’s do an entire season filled withSurvivoralumni! When it comes to casting former castaways on thesereality competition shows, they’re simply on another level. To compare it to another competition, it’s like having the varsity squad play with the freshmen on junior varsity.Survivorcastaways enter these games with advantages and disadvantages, buttheir ability to play has proven that it’s far superior to the non-gamers among them.
In the three seasons ofThe Traitorsand the two seasons ofDeal or No Deal Island, a handful ofSurvivorlegends have played and dominated. In fact,twoSurvivorwinners have participated in both contests.Yes, the players picked from the franchise are known for their strategic mastery, so when you put them in a field of civilians or reality stars originating from docufollow series, it’s embarrassing to see them try to keep up.
Survivors Thrive on ‘Deal Or No Deal Island’
Let’s begin with an examination of theSurvivors onDeal or No Deal Island. In the inaugural season, the series featured two reality stars. First, it was former case girl andThe Real Housewives of Atlantapeach holderClaudia JordanalongsideSurvivorlegendBoston Rob Mariano. Comparing the two, Claudia may have been a civilian. She didn’t let her celebrity aid her as she wasn’t recognized in the same manner Boston Rob was. From the jump,he was seen as a threat and a villain.The players knew who he was, and he had to adapt. Like he did onSurvivor: Redemption Island, he found a minion inAron Barbelland used him to aid his game. Boston Rob likely would have won the game had he not misplayed and cheated in the final excursion. He was able to use his social capital and strategic expertise to further himself. Even in the challenges, he used his vast playing experience to compete at a level unmatched.
10 Reality Stars Who Could Win ‘Squid Game’
The Front Man better beware of these reality stars!
For Season 2,Deal or No Deal IslandrecruitedSurvivor: MicronesiawinnerParvati ShallowandDavid Genat, also known as the Golden God, winner ofAustralian Survivor: All Stars. For this lot of players, the Golden God has gone undetected, which is to his benefit. He’s not seen as a threat for his past, but little do they know he’s a strong competitor. Now for Parvati, she’s been detected as the leader of the Black Widow Brigade, andshe’s using her past to dictate her game.She knows she has a target on her back, but the moment thatDr. Will KirbyofBig Brotherfame arrived, she is now able to take a backseat. If anyone knows her resume though, they should know their fate is sealed.
Smart ‘Survivor’ Strategy Brings Success on ‘The Traitors’
Now, toThe Traitors. There’s a reason why Boston Rob and Parvati have played both games.Their strategic prowess in games that require skillful strategy makes them perfect players.At this moment, Boston Rob is still playing as a traitor. His unique situation of entering the game as a traitor after being banished has allowed him to take a slight backseat until he completely dismantled the game of one of his own,Bob the Drag Queen, when he subtly put a target on his back. On Season 2, Parvati originally started as a faithful, but when she was recruited to play as a traitor, her game completely changed. She was forced to play a completely defensive game, that ultimately led to her downfall. She seemed like an obvious person to play as a traitor. So she was snuffed out. Especially since her one-timeSurvivorrival,Sandra Diaz-Twine, played as a faithful.
Season 1 saw twoSurvivors play the game. First,Stephanie LaGrossofloated pretty far into the game as a faithful, using her strong alliance-building skills. Then, oneSurvivorlegend, perhaps the best player to never win the game, was able to finally earn a reality television show victory by being the inaugural winner ofThe Traitors. For the first season, it was reality stars and civilians combined.Cirie Fieldsplayed as a traitor, a gift to gleeful fans. The woman who got off the couchused every skill that made her aSurvivorgreat to build social bonds to trick civilian faithfuls in handing her the grand prize.From there, anySurvivorcastaway who arrived at Alan Cumming’s castle thereafter had to play harder and smarter. Now in Season 3, theSurvivorquota was lifted to four. Thus far, the two castaways who were not traitors,Jeremy CollinsandTony Vlachos, have been murdered or banished. It leaves Boston Rob andCarolyn Wiger, who is on track to win the entire game, playing the same eccentric game with her whimsical personality.
What’s been proven faithfully thus far is thathaving a reputation fromSurvivormeans relying on the strengths to outplay, outwit, and outlast the non-gamersin their midst. Every winner ofThe Traitorshas come from a competition show. These strategic gamers are simply cut from a different cloth. There’s no comparison. If you’re not a castaway, you’re in over your head. Perhaps for Season 4, The Traitors should bring in those lesser brilliant characters who weren’t known for their brains to even the playing field. I’ve got that list ready to go if ya need it Peacock!
A reality show where a group of contestants are stranded in a remote location with little more than the clothes on their back. The lone survivor of this contest takes home a million dollars.
Survivoris available to stream on Paramount+
Stream on Paramount+
