The 2009Star Trekfilm by directorJ.J. Abramsmanaged to save a franchise that was borderline extinct. After the critical and commercial underperformance ofStar Trek: Nemesis, as well as the cancelation ofStar Trek: Enterprise, “trekkies” would not have been blamed for thinking that they would never be able to “live long and prosper” on the big screen ever again. However, the 2009 film managed to hook a new audience to theStar Treklore by presenting charismatic young stars to play younger versions of the characters first introduced in the original series. AlthoughChris Pine’s performance wascertainly worthy of praise,Sebastian Stanauditioned toplay Captain Kirk inStar Trek.
Chris Pine Almost Didn’t Play Captain Kirk
Given the pressure put onStar Trekto ensure the success of the franchise,the casting of a young Kirk was an extremely important decisionthat forced producers to do a wide search for potential talent. WhileWilliam Shatner’s performance is almost synonymous withthe science fiction genre itself,the young actor cast as Kirk had to have a unique spin on the role so that it did not feel entirely derivative of the past. Pine was a relative unknown when he earned the role, as his only real standout credits previously had been the cult comedyBottle Shockand the romantic comedyThe Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement. While his role in the threeStar Trekfilms certainly elevatedPine’s star status, Stan admitted that he “desperately wanted” the part and got “really close” to landing it.
While Stan admitted that he had become obsessed with trying to recapture a lot of Shatner’s mannerisms during his screen test with Paramount Pictures,Pine was able to offer a different perspective on Kirk. The version of the futureEnterprisecaptain that audiences meet at the beginning ofStar Trekis simply an irresponsible underachiever who lives within the shadow of his departed father, George (Chris Hemsworth). Although Kirk initially has a lot of feuds with Spock (Zachary Quinto), he begins to mature as a leader as he develops a deep level of respect for every single member of his crew. It’s remarkable to see how wellhe transitioned the characterthroughout all three films; by the end ofStar Trek Beyond, Pine’s version of Kirk has the confidence, charisma,and heroism that is reminiscentof Shatner.
Why We Haven’t Gotten a New ‘Star Trek’ Movie Yet
The ‘Star Trek’ franchise seems to be thriving everywhere except the silver screen.
Sebastian Stan Would Have Been a Good Fit for ‘Star Trek'
While Pine’s inherent likability certainly helped make theStar Trekreboot more approachable for non-fans,Stan may have been able to delve into the feelings of self-doubtthat Kirk faces in the film. Kirk is driven to succeed after Captain Pike (Bruce Greenwood) informs him about his father’s legacy. However, he spends most of the film wondering whether he is actually worthy of having the same family name. This level of interposition is key to many of Stan’s best performances; he showed the redemptive arc of Bucky Barnes within the Marvel Cinematic Universe, examined the plight of a struggling actor inA Different Man, and even captured the“rags to riches” story of Donald Trump inThe Apprentice.Humor was certainly integral to the newStar Trekfilms, but Stan showed he had comedic talents inLogan LuckyandPam & Tommy.
One of the primary reasons thatStar Treksucceededcompared to other rebootswas that it embraced the ensemble nature of the franchise. While the original series largely focused on Kirk, Spock (Leonard Nimoy), and McCoy (DeForest Kelly), Abrams ensured that every crew member was given a substantial role.Stan has proven that he is an excellent ensemble playerwho can support his co-stars. Although Bucky has never led a solo MCU film, Stan has been able to support other actors he appeared alongside. Though Pine played the part well, Stan could have offered a different but still amazing performance. Given that Paramount Plus is intent on expanding theStar Trekfranchise with multiple television spin-offs planned, Stan will hopefully get the chance at some point to appear within the universe that he clearly has a lot of passion for.
J.J. Abrams' 2009 movie Star Trek rebooted the iconic sci-fi franchise in a totally new timeline. When a Romulan ship travels back in time and alters the past, the lives of James T. Kirk (Chris Pine), Spock (Zachary Quinto), and the future crew of the USS Enterprise are drastically changed. In this new timeline, the Romulan Nero (Eric Bana) sets out for revenge on Spock, setting off a chain of events that reshape the entire universe.
Star Trekis streaming on Paramount Plus in the U.S.
Watch on Paramount Plus
